PIX instant payment system in Brazil faces US scrutiny over card network competition claims

Brazil’s instant payment tool PIX has become a daily habit across political divides. People use it for small treats and major purchases. The system handled about USD 7 trillion in transactions last year. It is now under US scrutiny. US officials say PIX may harm card networks like Visa and Mastercard.

Representative image

Unlike many bank-owned apps, PIX is overseen by Brazil’s Central Bank. The service supports real-time transfers using a Brazilian bank account. Access is open to people with a Brazilian taxpayer identification. Registered firms and government bodies can also use it. Users can also pay through QR codes.

PIX instant payment system faces US Trade Representative inquiry

In July, the Office of the US Trade Representative (USTR) under US President Donald Trump opened an inquiry. The USTR alleged PIX creates unfair competition for US credit card operators. The concern focuses on PIX offering an option that avoids transaction fees. This may reduce reliance on traditional credit networks.

India runs a similar instant payment system. It is not being challenged by the USTR. The Indian system processed USD 300 billion in payments in March alone. Like PIX, it charges no transaction fees. The comparison has drawn attention as the US inquiry develops.

PIX fees, speed and everyday use drive adoption

PIX launched in 2020 and is designed for immediate transfers. Individuals pay zero fees for PIX transfers. Some banks charge companies, but amounts are lower than standard transfers. Older transfers can take hours in Brazil. PIX also supports QR payments in shops and public places.

The best payment method is PIX, the most used, said Luis Felipe de Almeida, a 21-year-old vendor of iced tea and cassava starch biscuits on Ipanema beach in Rio de Janeiro. No one walks around with cash anymore, everyone just uses their phone, so they use PIX.

Many middle-class Brazilians rely on PIX for both minor and large payments. Marcello Palladini, a 57-year-old restaurant owner in Sao Paulo, uses it for supplier payments. He said he often uses PIX for amounts above 1,000 Brazilian reais (USD 200). Some suppliers do not accept cards for such sums.

When I want something quickly, I pay with PIX and it comes right away. I also do PIX with some suppliers who keep a tab and at the end of the month they send me a full bill, Palladini said. He added that many lunch customers still choose credit cards or meal vouchers.

Palladini objected to what he called uneven bank fees for companies. Even so, he backed the system’s convenience. PIX works great, it is all instant, he said. Beyond restaurants, large companies use PIX to pay workers. Brazilians can also buy houses, cars, and helicopters through PIX.

PIX fraud, phone theft and security controls

Authorities say PIX’s success has also created openings for crime. Some gangs steal phones and move money instantly. This can involve transfers of tens of thousands of Brazilian reais. Police, banks, and insurers have struggled with the speed of stolen funds. The technology works fast, even for criminals.

Brazilian authorities and firms have increased monitoring for suspicious activity. They often track and close bank accounts linked to irregular transfers. They also cap PIX transfers from 8 pm until the next morning. The goal is to limit large moves when many users miss phone alerts about transactions.

The Brazilian Forum of Public Security, a think-tank, estimated major reach for PIX-related crime. It said between 24 million and 28 million people were affected. The period covered January to September of last year. The group did not estimate total losses. The figures added pressure for added safeguards.

From the technical and legal standpoint, PIX is safe. But it is not immune to fraud because its risks are not in its technology; they are in people trying to fool others, said Ana Paula Siqueira, an expert on Brazils digital law. The most common fraud involves psychological manipulation, fake IDs, urgent requests for payment.

Even with these risks, PIX registration has spread widely. About 178 million of Brazil’s 213 million residents have signed up. At street markets, sellers also promote the speed of payment. Love doesnt happen suddenly, it takes time, shouted Claudia Quirino, a vendor of Brazilian dumplings at an open-air market in the Sao Paulo region of Pinheiros. But PIX is instant! Buy now!

With inputs from PTI