India Disputes IMFs Projection of General Government Debt Exceeding 100% of GDP

In a recent statement, the Indian Ministry of Finance has refuted the International Monetary Fund's (IMF) projection that the country's general government debt will surpass 100% of its GDP by 2027-28. The ministry asserts that this interpretation is misconstrued and highlights several factors that support India's position.

Representative image

Comparative Analysis with Other Countries

The finance ministry emphasizes that several other nations are anticipated to fare worse than India regarding debt. For instance, the worst-case scenarios for the United States, the United Kingdom, and China stand at approximately 160%, 140%, and 200%, respectively, significantly higher than India's projected 100% debt-to-GDP ratio.

Potential Decline in Debt-to-GDP Ratio

The ministry also draws attention to the IMF report's indication that under favorable circumstances, India's general government debt-to-GDP ratio could decline below 70% during the same period. This suggests that the interpretation of the report implying an inevitable exceedance of 100% debt-to-GDP in the medium term is inaccurate.

Declining Debt Trend

The finance ministry further points out that the general government debt, including both state and central levels, has witnessed a significant decline from approximately 88% in the fiscal year 2020-21 to around 81% in 2022-23. The central government remains on track to achieve its stated fiscal consolidation target of reducing the fiscal deficit below 4.5% of GDP by the fiscal year 2025-26.

Fiscal Responsibility Legislation

The ministry also highlights that individual states have enacted their fiscal responsibility legislation, monitored by their respective state legislatures. This framework is expected to contribute to a substantial decline in general government debt in the medium to long term.

IMF's Assessment and Recommendations

The IMF's Article IV consultation report earlier this week acknowledged that while India's budget deficit has eased, public debt remains elevated, necessitating the rebuilding of fiscal buffers. The report suggests additional revenue and expenditure measures, such as further GST and subsidy reforms, while prioritizing public investment and targeted support for vulnerable populations.

India's Debt Composition and Risk Mitigation

In defending India's position, the finance ministry emphasizes that the country's general government debt is predominantly rupee-denominated, with minimal external borrowings from bilateral and multilateral sources. This aspect has been acknowledged in the IMF report. Domestically issued debt, primarily in the form of government bonds, is mostly medium or long-term, with a weighted average maturity of roughly 12 years for central government debt. Consequently, the rollover risk for domestic debt is low, and exposure to exchange rate volatility is relatively limited.

Global Shocks and Comparative Performance

The finance ministry acknowledges that the shocks experienced by India in the current century, such as the global financial crisis, taper tantrum, COVID-19 pandemic, and Russia-Ukraine conflict, were global in nature and uniformly affected the global economy. The ministry asserts that few countries remained entirely unaffected by these events. Therefore, any adverse global shock or extreme event is likely to impact all economies in an interconnected and globalized world.

India's Favorable Debt Position

The ministry concludes by stating that a cross-country comparison reveals that India has performed relatively well and currently maintains a debt level below that of 2002. This indicates India's effective management of its debt situation.