Agrochemical Industry Bodies Oppose Maharashtras Criminalization Bills

Representative image

In a significant development, leading agro-chemical industry bodies in India have come together to oppose the criminalisation of various offences proposed by the Maharashtra government. The Crop Care Federation of India (CCFI), CropLife India (CLI), Pesticides Manufacturers and Formulators Association of India (PMFAI), and Agro Chem Federation of India (ACFI) have expressed their concerns over four bills that the state government intends to push through during the winter session of the legislative assembly, commencing in Nagpur on Thursday.

Bills Deemed Disproportionately Harsh and Ambiguous

In a joint statement, the industry bodies have raised serious objections to the proposed bills, describing them as "disproportionately harsh, ambiguous, and contrary to the initiatives of the central government for ease of doing business and decriminalisation." They argue that the Insecticide Act, a central government act, already contains stringent provisions with appropriate clauses to penalise those who fail to adhere to its requirements.

Genuine Manufacturers Fear Unfair Targeting

The industry bodies have expressed apprehension that the additional powers sought by the Maharashtra government to act against adulterated, fake, and duplicate inputs could be misused to target genuine manufacturers. They have urged that the proposed bills should not be passed, as they pose a significant threat to the operations of legitimate businesses in the state.

Repeated Submissions and Urgent Appeal for Hearing

The manufacturers and sellers of seeds, fertilisers, and pesticides have made repeated submissions to the Maharashtra Agriculture Minister and officials over the past two months, expressing their concerns about the proposed bills. They have now made an urgent plea for a hearing before the commencement of the Winter Session in Nagpur, seeking an opportunity to present their case and address the government's concerns.

Overview of the Proposed Bills

The first bill proposes to provide compensation to farmers for losses incurred due to the sale and use of adulterated, non-standard, or misbranded seeds, fertilisers, or insecticides in Maharashtra. The second bill seeks to amend the Insecticides Act 1968 in its application to the state, while the third bill proposes amendments to the Seeds Act 1955. The fourth bill aims to further amend the Maharashtra Prevention of Dangerous Activities (MPDA) of Slumlords, Bootleggers, Drug Offenders, Dangerous Persons, Video Pirates, Sand Smugglers, and Persons Engaged in Black Marketing of Essential Commodities Act 1981.

Concerns over Preventive Detention and Unlimited Powers

The industry bodies have raised specific concerns about the MPDA Act, which provides for preventive detention of offenders and makes even minor offences cognisable and non-bailable. They fear that the police will have unlimited powers to arrest individuals without being adequately equipped to handle the technicalities of seeds, fertilisers, pesticides, insecticides, and the central laws governing them. This, they argue, could lead to harassment and unfair targeting of manufacturers and sellers.

Challenges for Genuine Manufacturers and Stakeholders

The industry bodies contend that the proposed amendments make it virtually impossible for genuine manufacturers and stakeholders to conduct business in Maharashtra. The looming threat of arrest and detention in police custody without recourse to bail, even for minor offences, discourages companies from nominating responsible persons, hindering their ability to operate effectively.

Existing Penal Provisions and Potential Consequences

CropLife India Chairman KC Ravi emphasised that sufficient penal provisions already exist under the Insecticide Act 1968 to enable law enforcement agencies to take action against spurious seeds, fertilisers, and pesticides. He expressed concern that a single complaint from a farmer regarding issues with pesticides, seeds, or insecticides could lead to trouble for corporates, as any person nominated as the company's representative could be arrested on a non-bailable complaint.

Industry's Concern over Clubbing with Dangerous Persons

The agri-inputs industry, comprising seed manufacturers, pesticide makers, crop protection, and formulation manufacturers, is particularly worried about the clubbing of the four sectors with dangerous persons, drug offenders, and slum lords in the proposed bills. They believe that such categorisation is unwarranted and undermines the reputation of legitimate businesses.

Call for Fair and Balanced Approach

Pradip P Dave of PMFAI expressed the industry's deep concern over the indiscriminate nature of the proposed bills, which make many offences cognisable and non-bailable irrespective of their gravity. He emphasised that such provisions, if implemented, would create immense fear of unfair prosecutions among genuine manufacturers and authorised distributors who have consistently worked to provide quality inputs to farmers.

The opposition from leading agro-chemical industry bodies to the proposed bills in Maharashtra highlights the need for a fair and balanced approach to regulating the sector. The concerns raised by the industry regarding disproportionate penalties, ambiguity, and the potential for misuse of powers underscore the importance of considering the impact on legitimate businesses and ensuring that genuine manufacturers are not unfairly targeted. As the Maharashtra government prepares to discuss these bills during the upcoming legislative assembly session, it will be crucial to address the industry's concerns and find a solution that protects farmers' interests while fostering a conducive environment for businesses to operate.